There should be some flexibility with that rule - the original title is very uninformative, and the changed version ("Google introduces webcam "liveness check" option to reCAPTCHA") summarizes the content fairly and honestly.
belter · 15h ago
This is is deeply troubling and underscores why companies like Google must be broken up entirely.
I’ve never had a Facebook account, but I saw an acquaintance try to sign up. To my shock, Facebook requires new users to enable their camera and take a selfie to "prove you're human."
This isn't just about access, it's biometric data collection...That selfie is scanned, stored, and likely used to train and feed current and future AI systems, enabling surveillance and tracking across the web and physical world.
Now Google appears to be moving in the same direction testing similar biometric requirements maybe just to access content like YouTube videos. This is not about fighting bots. It's about cementing their role as digital gatekeepers with unchecked power.
And it’s a warning. We are entering an era where personal identity becomes the price of admission to the internet.
This is a clear reason why Google must be broken up...Now.
kossTKR · 15h ago
Tangent but isn't this easily circumvented by Veo 3 and other newer models - when they become fast enough to respond quickly in a few years?
I wonder how long before the internet will become 100% bot noise - even previously valuable last bastions like hackernews, only battled with some kind of actually clever and at least semi anonymous Homo Sapiens verifier.
Is anything in the pipelines or will we eventually end up with some kind of Human ID's, and can be anonymised?
move-on-by · 11h ago
Both ‘Fall; or, Dodge in Hell’ and ‘Anathem’ by Neal Stephenson have very bleak outlooks for the future of the internet that I see playing out today. Being riddled with bots and false but plausible misinformation.
[1] https://patents.google.com/patent/US9407661
> Please use the original title
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
I’ve never had a Facebook account, but I saw an acquaintance try to sign up. To my shock, Facebook requires new users to enable their camera and take a selfie to "prove you're human."
This isn't just about access, it's biometric data collection...That selfie is scanned, stored, and likely used to train and feed current and future AI systems, enabling surveillance and tracking across the web and physical world.
Now Google appears to be moving in the same direction testing similar biometric requirements maybe just to access content like YouTube videos. This is not about fighting bots. It's about cementing their role as digital gatekeepers with unchecked power.
And it’s a warning. We are entering an era where personal identity becomes the price of admission to the internet.
This is a clear reason why Google must be broken up...Now.
I wonder how long before the internet will become 100% bot noise - even previously valuable last bastions like hackernews, only battled with some kind of actually clever and at least semi anonymous Homo Sapiens verifier.
Is anything in the pipelines or will we eventually end up with some kind of Human ID's, and can be anonymised?