What do people use for on-call these days?

4 skullum 6 5/16/2025, 7:41:25 PM
Pagerduty feels like it used to be the dominant player especially for small teams but I found it surprisingly expensive and cumbersome to use for a small team and Ops-genie is EOL, splunk on-call feels weird to use w/o splunk.

Comments (6)

jjtang1 · 9h ago
JJ here, obviously bias as I am the founder of Rootly.com that's building in this space.

We are a modern AI-native on-call and incident management platform here at Rootly.com. We are helping fast-growing companies like from Replit, Figma, NVIDIA, and 100s of others respond faster.

Some of the biggest frustrations with legacy providers like PagerDuty (who I have a lot of respect for in pioneering on-call) is their lack of innovation (only a phone call) and how expensive it is.

Some fan favourites include request coverage for overrides, automatic adjustments based on PTO and holidays, native Slack/Teams collaboration (not just paging), native shadow rotations, syncing with Slack user groups, a beautiful UI and mobile app, and an all-in-one platform for status pages, workflows, communications, retrospectives, and metrics.

If you're a small team Rootly has a pretty discounted version for startups. Here is a full comparison if you're interested: https://rootly.com/comparisons/pagerduty-vs-rootly-on-call

simantel · 9h ago
Pretty much everyone still uses PagerDuty, but Incident.io is starting to be competitive as well.

I've never heard of anyone using Opsgenie or Splunk for on-call, and Opsgenie's 3-week outage or whatever is pretty damning.

jjtang1 · 9h ago
Def worth taking a look at Rootly On-Call, we've helped everyone from Rivian to Brex migrate over from PagerDuty :)
bnchrch · 9h ago
The biggest knock against pagerduty is its both expensive and doesnt have simple features like connecting Pagerduty schedules to slack user groups.

For example if I want to have a slack group that pings (not pages) to current oncall person

```

@oc-platform

```

I need to pay $25/month to a random third party slack app.

Its insane, do they even use pagerduty internally?

jjtang1 · 9h ago
Tbh this took us about a day to build and well worth it. Makes on-call lives so much easier. Not sure why they don't yet https://rootly.com/changelog/sync-on-call-schedules-with-sla.... Sorry to be promotional.
markus_zhang · 7h ago
Just PD and hopefuy it does not ring up after 12am.