Ask HN: Passion vs. Tools. Which drove your career?

1 ednite 2 8/31/2025, 12:29:43 PM
I’m curious about the paths that led people here: how many of you started your careers not out of burning passion, but for comfort, stability, or opportunity?

Did you later find passion along the way, or did it never come?

The debate is often framed as "follow your passion" (the Joseph Campbell model) vs. "follow your tools and skills" (à la Cal Newport). I recently watched a video that strongly advocated for the "tools-first" approach, and it forced me to articulate my own perspective, which is that, in my opinion, the most sustainable path is a blend of both.

In my case, I prove both theories:

- Passion as the Compass: A long-held interest in storytelling sparks my pursuits.

- Tools as the Engine: My career in IT, which I entered for stability, gave me the resources and discipline to actually build things. Mastery did, in fact, build passion in that field.

This tension led me to flesh out my thoughts, but I'm ultimately more interested in the community's experience.

Which came first for you: the passion, or the tools (skills, classes, opportunities)?

Comments (2)

JohnFen · 4h ago
It's not even close. Passion. I only developed tools and skills as a means to better pursue my interest. The prospect of doing this as a career never entered into it -- that came more as a side-effect.
ednite · 4h ago
I love this. Your experience is what everyone hopes for and it reinforces my perspective on how passion and purpose intersect. Thanks for sharing!