Cloudflare confirms downtime on August 23rd, silently posts it on status page

The book by Mashaal and a book by Aczel (which I enjoyed) were reviewed by Michael Atiyah (1966 Fields Medalist): "Bourbaki, A Secret Society of Mathematicians" (Maurice Mashaal) and "The Artist and the Mathematician" (Amir Aczel) - Notices of the American Mathematical Society, v. 54, no. 9, October, 2007 - https://www.ams.org/notices/200709/tx070901150p.pdf

There have been numerous articles about Bourbaki, including some by former Bourbaki members:

"The Work of Bourbaki During the Last Thirty Years" - Jean Dieudonne - Notices of the American Mathematical Society, v. 29, no. 7, November, 1982 - https://www.ams.org/journals/notices/198211/198211FullIssue....

"Twenty-Five Years with Nicolas Bourbaki, 1949–1973" - Armand Borel - Notices of the American Mathematical Society, v. 45, no. 3, March, 1998 - https://www.ams.org//journals/notices/199803/borel.pdf

Edit: fixed typo

kzz102 · 2h ago

It's interesting that while Bourbaki had a large influence on modern mathematics, very few people read their books (at least among the people I know). In a sense, their project of producing a definitive exposition for a large part of mathematics has failed. I wonder whether it's because different branches of mathematics have their unique personalities, and therefore the attempt to provide a unified point of view are bound to fail.

madcaptenor · 2h ago

Also mathematicians tend to not read "the classics" of the field. Do the people you know read other math books from the same time period?

kzz102 · 21m ago

I was applying a unfair standard to them of course. Every field has a few classics that last a long time, but most old books are not read. But I think Bourbaki maybe had grand ambitions that were eventually unrealized. My theory is that the presentation of mathematics is not based on unifying principles, but rather on the collective taste of mathematicians. So what end up being the most popular books is based on how the collective taste evolve.

throwaway81523 · 1h ago

Yes, Whitaker & Watson (analysis), Hardy and Wright (number theory), Dieudonne (analysis and he was literally a Bourbaki member), heck, Euclid's Elements; Gauss Disquisitiones, etc. Bourbaki is more of a monument. Writing it was necessary, but for readers it suffices to know that it is there ;).

Davidzheng · 1h ago

while it's certainly not read by most mathematicians, Bourbaki (especially set theory & general topology) are still quite often read by mathematicians in training I believe.

throwaway81523 · 1h ago

The set theory book is, at best, very outdated. No idea about topology.

euiq · 40m ago

General Topology is valuable, especially for the filter perspective; so are some of the Algebra volumes.

ysofunny · 1h ago

they provided a unified point of view by explaining it all in terms of sets

ultimately they failed because they wrote such that it didn't matter if other people understood. it's a style that is only intelligible if you already know (from some other experience) what they are describing.

kirubakaran · 2h ago

We had our own: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=nickb

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

throwaway81523 · 1h ago

Book is from 2006, title should note this. Publication page: https://bookstore.ams.org/bourbaki

TZubiri · 31m ago

The link seems broken, points to books.google.com for me

tzury · 2h ago

this is the link I posted. not sure why it got modified

https://books.google.ae/books?id=-CXn6y_1nJ8C&pg=PA18&redir_...

Zambyte · 3h ago

If you want a very deep rabbit hole to go down, look into the connections between the Bourbaki group and Twenty One Pilots lore :)

futura_heavy · 2h ago

He goes by Nico, fwiw.

itsthecourier · 3h ago

https://www.google.com.do/books/edition/Bourbaki/-CXn6y_1nJ8...

this one?

tzury · 2h ago

https://books.google.ae/books?id=-CXn6y_1nJ8C&pg=PA18&redir_...

yes, this is the original link I submitted. not sure why it was modified.

fritzo · 2h ago

"secret society" -> "anonymous publishing group"

Guthur · 2h ago

Potato -> Po Ta To

suspended_state · 25m ago

https://copilot.microsoft.com/shares/3E6yBbwom9rEqqMnE5m75

siliconunit · 2h ago

imagine having to rigorously prove that blood is really essential for the survival of a human being before every surgery, thanks Bourbaki. /s

Cloudflare confirms downtime on August 23rd, silently posts it on status page

Ask HN: The government of my country blocked VPN access. What should I use?

Ask HN: What to learn for math for modeling?

Ask HN: Best self-hosted wiki solution in 2025? Mediawiki or something else?

Ask HN: Should we stop worrying that AI will replace developer jobs?

Ask HN: What options do I have for self-hosted end to end encrypted group chat?

Ask HN: Theory That Economic Growth Stagnates in a Civilization

Ask HN: Why hasn't x86 caught up with Apple M series?

Ask HN: Daily/weekly/monthly technical rituals?

Tired of Broken .onion Links? I Built a Real-Time Tor SE That Works

Ask HN: What to do when you suspect your interview is with a state operative?

Ask HN: How can I recover and run my old mobile game from the 2010s?

Ask HN: Avoiding AI slop in music services

Apple App Store Review Mess

Best up-to-date guides on Vibe Coding

Ask HN: Where can I see a live octopus in Maine?

Ask HN: Anyone working on bringing software back from US clouds?

Staying up to date on the best AI dev workflow?

Ask HN: How much better can the LLMs become assuming no AGI

Ask HN: Did modern AI's coding abilities make you lose interest in programming?

Ask HN: Services for Shutting Down a Startup?

Ask HN: What to Do with Old iPads?

CompactifAI Inference API

Ask HN: What are the best Google alternatives in 2025?

Ask HN: GitHub Copilot down?

Ask HN: Best codebases to study to learn software design?

Ask HN: How to teach a 4 year old to code?

Petition to stop Google from restricting sideloading and FOSS apps

Ask HN: Is there a temp phone number like temp email?

Ask HN: Does sentience put stress on the brain?

Ask HN: Why are so many services rejecting Google Voice numbers for signups?

Stop squashing your commits. You're squashing your AI too

Ask HN: How to Learn to Build Agentic AI Systems (Like Claude Code)

Ask HN: Are AI filters becoming stricter than society itself?

Ask HN: What should I use to run React Native tests on a device?

Ask HN: What measures are you taking to stop AI crawlers?

Ask HN: Is backlink trading still a problem worth solving?

Bourbaki – A Secret Society of Mathematicians

Comments (21)