Ask HN: There is a HR vicious cycle in the current market?

2 major505 5 5/20/2025, 12:35:08 PM
Time for some controversial question:

Yesterday I was reflecting on my current job search, and been founding out that scoring interviews became increasing difficult in the last couple of years.

Specially the ammount of not responses or ghosting I been hearing from employers.

At the same time I been seeing a lot of posts from managers and CEOs complaining that its been difficulting hiring and filling positions at their companies.

So I was thinking what was my biggest obstacles and changes I observed: IA tools became avaliable in the last years and widelly used in most HRs departments. So I acceded a payed service called Kick Resume, and found out my resume scored very low when an AI reviewed it. Maybe one of the walls I been hitting is the increase widespread of such tools in HR departments, and imagine how many good engineers and developers are having the same trouble.

At the same time, every company seens to think they are google, and when you pass the AI analitics phase, they want to schedulle 4, 5 interviews with you for the hiring process.

And when you are without a job, and needing money, you don't have this luxury, so you just greabb the first offer that comes to you, even if is not the best or most suitable for your skill set.

In response to this difficult to hire, many CEOs are investing in more HR professionals for recruiting purpose. So, honest question: are HR creating more difficult than helping by feeding this system?

Comments (5)

ljf · 1d ago
On a personal note - I always advise friends to tailor their CV for every application. It is a pain and it takes time, but the days of just submitting 'your CV' for every job are gone.

If the job spec says 'Team management' and your CV says 'People leader', change it to match the spec. One it helps if the employer does use AI, and two if there is a first round human filter, they will likely be looking for the exact keywords they are expecting.

Maybe this is something that AI could be good for, truthfully updating your CV to align with the job advert?

JohnFen · 1d ago
> I always advise friends to tailor their CV for every application.

This is absolutely key and always has been. I'm often surprised that there are people who don't do this.

ljf · 1d ago
I review a lot of CVs and it is clear a lot of people don’t update. I always have since the 00s but I don’t think we are the majority.
major505 · 1d ago
yea, I found a application called kick resume where you put the job description and it helps. Saves a lot of time, but you still need to pass a fine comb over it.

Is kinda expensive, but lets see if if pays itself.

PaulHoule · 1d ago
People have been saying things like this for the past 30 years or so.