Great work! The video does state this clearly that it was about the journey first and foremost and that's great, but yet to me it feels unfinished when it ends as soon as we get to the really fun stuff, so it's complete in the sense of it being well-produced, publishable content, but it's uploaded as soon as it's publishable, and I'm left with "what, that's it?", as I've mostly been looking at milling and some coating. I get this often with similar videos today. Either it's just me (entirely possible) or it's a sign of the times.
untech · 1h ago
It takes some sifting to find some really good “making” channels on YT. I’ve watched this video and while I applaud author’s efforts, I don’t consider this type of content “good enough” to be subscribing. It felt overproduced and with too epic tone, while giving too little detail on the process, the experimentation, the actual solution (he said ratios are important, but what ratios did he use) and no thorough explanation of what is happening.
The golden standard is Applied Science channel, of course, but there are some smaller channels with similar vibe.
fourside · 3m ago
Please share the smaller channels if you have them handy! I’m very interested.
vintermann · 1h ago
A lot of honest projects are going to end this way, with a sort of half-failure. YouTube channels which show it anyway are more credible than the ones who seem to always succeed at whatever they're trying.
ginko · 2h ago
Yeah, I was hoping he'd get it at least to a somewhat usable state where you can at least load a small file (maybe with some file system sector fiddling).
mcdonje · 2h ago
Title: "I"
First line: "[YouTuber] PolyMatt"
The article just advertises the video. This post could be just the video.
bookofjoe · 1h ago
I for one never ever click on a video link here. I suspect I'm not alone.
5555624 · 1h ago
You're not. I'll only click on a video, here, after checking the comments
debesyla · 1h ago
It's interesting how HN crowd are mostly text (and text with low formatting too!) consumers. Compared to other social media, and even old school forums...
Are we mostly l33t developers here, in love with CLI and Vim? Ha!
stavros · 46m ago
Come on, it's absurd to think that we all follow a stereotype. Some of us use emacs.
bookofjoe · 1h ago
In the beginning was the command line
nlitsme · 15m ago
there is no explanation on how to get the very fine black iron oxide powder in the video, it just appears out of nowhere.
zabzonk · 1h ago
In the early 80s, a lot of the floppy disks and drives I had to use could have been crafted by cavemen out of a Far Side cartoon.
EvanAnderson · 1h ago
I watched the video when it made the rounds last week. I was impressed with the work and the results. I did wonder, though, if a 5 1/4" disk would have been an easier initial goal, seeing as how the outer envelope is a lot less involved than a 3 1/2".
Joel_Mckay · 2h ago
These kinds of hobbies always teach people more than expected.
He gets surprisingly close to viable storage media. Nicely done =3
smokel · 3h ago
Hehe, very nice to see something outside the scope of software or PCBs with this level of useless enthusiasm.
Obviously "from scratch" is a bit of a stretch here, but this is the material we come to Hacker News for.
Thanks for sharing!
Edit: sigh, I should probably run my comments through ChatGPT to avoid being downvoted. I like this, I share my enthusiasm. I like the uselessness of it, meaning the uselessness of making a floppy disk in 2025, not the lack of educational value. Sheesh.
hnlmorg · 28m ago
Your definition of “from scratch” is pretty unrealistic.
If someone was to say “make a pasta source from scratch” then that wouldn’t mean refining your own copper to make your source pans.
The problem is creating the floppy disk. Not the tooling to create the floppy disk.
MrGilbert · 3h ago
Judging from the video, it looks pretty "from scratch" to me. What makes it a "bit of a stretch" to you?
smokel · 2h ago
He uses quite a bit of tooling, including lasers. It's not like he would be able to get this far in the middle of nowhere :)
In a way it is somewhat similar to people writing demos for old computers using emulators. Still great fun, but using these tools it doesn't take a village to make one floppy disk. With modern hardware you are apparently able to pull this off on your own. That would have been almost impossible in the 1980s, when these floppy disks were popular.
I probably worded it badly, but I really enjoy these efforts, and I would never be able to do this myself, even if I had a shed with all those tools!
cluckindan · 2h ago
Are you even a musician if you don’t have a goat farm?
How can someone call themselves a programmer when they don’t even mine for silicon!
debesyla · 1h ago
I couldn't find an answer on google - how is a goat farm precursor for music? It's an activity that needs herding and shepherds started playing songs for fun? Or..? :o
et-al · 39m ago
Stringed instruments use goat or sheep intestines. And drums are from their skin (leather).
https://youtu.be/TBiFGhnXsh8?si=wra84H0R8fy2XCnd
The golden standard is Applied Science channel, of course, but there are some smaller channels with similar vibe.
First line: "[YouTuber] PolyMatt"
The article just advertises the video. This post could be just the video.
Are we mostly l33t developers here, in love with CLI and Vim? Ha!
He gets surprisingly close to viable storage media. Nicely done =3
Thanks for sharing!
Edit: sigh, I should probably run my comments through ChatGPT to avoid being downvoted. I like this, I share my enthusiasm. I like the uselessness of it, meaning the uselessness of making a floppy disk in 2025, not the lack of educational value. Sheesh.
If someone was to say “make a pasta source from scratch” then that wouldn’t mean refining your own copper to make your source pans.
The problem is creating the floppy disk. Not the tooling to create the floppy disk.
In a way it is somewhat similar to people writing demos for old computers using emulators. Still great fun, but using these tools it doesn't take a village to make one floppy disk. With modern hardware you are apparently able to pull this off on your own. That would have been almost impossible in the 1980s, when these floppy disks were popular.
I probably worded it badly, but I really enjoy these efforts, and I would never be able to do this myself, even if I had a shed with all those tools!
How can someone call themselves a programmer when they don’t even mine for silicon!
why even bother
Mine and refine iron ore to make hub. Mine and refine zinc(?) to plate it.
Drill for and refine oil to make PET for disk and casing. Injection mold casing. Make film for actual disc.
Etc, etc.
I’d be ok using tools that weren’t made from scratch as well, but that’d be bonus ooints.