"The consequences for theft should include that the profit you made off of the theft is taken away."
That seems very reasonable. Otherwise, stealing money, lending it out for interest, and then returning the stolen money while keeping the interest would be a viable way to earn money.
"The cost of building a company on theft should be the company itself."
Also seems reasonable, because it is the same rule applied to AI companies.
I'd say leave 20% for the VCs and split the other 80% of Anthropic stock among the authors of affected books. That would surely discourage similar behavior in the future.
freejazz · 14m ago
>That seems very reasonable. Otherwise, stealing money, lending it out for interest, and then returning the stolen money while keeping the interest would be a viable way to earn money.
Copyright infringement plaintiffs are entitled to disgorge any profits a defendant made by infringing. As I pointed out upthread, Anthropic did not train on this dataset and therefore did not profit from it. The authors were instead seeking statutory damages for the pirating of the library.
freejazz · 15m ago
The settlement isn't even for anything they actually used. An insane blunder by Anthropic.
Given it's not data they trained on, I'm not sure the principles behind punishing them further.
That seems very reasonable. Otherwise, stealing money, lending it out for interest, and then returning the stolen money while keeping the interest would be a viable way to earn money.
"The cost of building a company on theft should be the company itself."
Also seems reasonable, because it is the same rule applied to AI companies.
I'd say leave 20% for the VCs and split the other 80% of Anthropic stock among the authors of affected books. That would surely discourage similar behavior in the future.
Copyright infringement plaintiffs are entitled to disgorge any profits a defendant made by infringing. As I pointed out upthread, Anthropic did not train on this dataset and therefore did not profit from it. The authors were instead seeking statutory damages for the pirating of the library.
Given it's not data they trained on, I'm not sure the principles behind punishing them further.
This article misses this crucial detail.