ASK: Could AI Replace the Slush Pile Intern?

1 richardatlarge 2 8/12/2025, 2:02:30 AM
A common lament of new fiction authors is the horribly named "slush pile," where submissions sit waiting for a lit agency "intern" to look at the length of the first few paragraphs and bin the ms. of the next Zadie Smith or Thomas Pynchon

So I wonder, could an LLM do a lot better?

Comments (2)

JojoFatsani · 5m ago
I don’t think a model will be able to handle the abstract concepts that make a good book worth reading.. it would be selecting for something predictable/boilerplate…

That said there’s zero doubt in my mind that they will be used heavily in the publishing industry.

al_borland · 9m ago
I don't know anything about this world, but judging a book of the length of the first paragraph seems incredibly shallow and easily gamed.