Trump orders firing of labor stats chief after data showed jobs growth slowed

19 throwaway5752 8 8/1/2025, 7:01:32 PM theguardian.com ↗

Comments (8)

exceptione · 8m ago
The media rooms in the US will discuss this like a regular infotainment item, making it look like a normal controversy. Then it will pushed out from the news by some other circus act.

For many, this will feel like a defensible move or a minor mistake. If the public discourse is corrupted, the public will be corrupted. And so the whole house will come down, just as intended.

NullHypothesist · 1h ago
This is what corruption looks like.
taylodl · 32m ago
This is what a dictatorship looks like.
belter · 1h ago
This is when a micro black hole cross the plane of the solar system, and your reality fuses with the Onion
jleyank · 1h ago
I thought the Onion gave up as they could not come with satire anymore. People kept thinking it was real news or commentary.
rhelz · 11m ago
I'm as big of a critic of Trump as you are likely to find but......the previous jobs reports was revised DOWNWARD by over a quarter of a million jobs.

Sure, you expect the numbers to change as more data comes in. But...that's a pretty big misoverestimate. This is very problematic, as it actually MASKED some of the ill effects which Trump's policies have had.

Who knows if Trump would have actually moderated his policies if he had had a more accurate read sooner, but private companies rely on this data as well, and no doubt they have made decisions they wouldn't have if they had know the true numbers.

Trump certainly was mean-spirited in trying to frame this as a partisan issue, and downright disingenuous in some of his accusations. Nevertheless, >250,000 jobs everybody thought were there but weren't....yeah, that's a firing offense.

littlexsparkee · 2m ago
ADP crunches the numbers too and they were more in line with the revised estimates - there was nothing preventing companies from acting on that. How can you claim this is fireable without context about how the calculations/revisions occur and their side of the story? These trade policies are engendering so much uncertainty, combined with the shakeup in the federal workforce - honestly something like this was pretty foreseeable...
throwaway5752 · 58m ago
I missed https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44760734 that previously posted about this.