Axios made the mistake of linking directly to X instead of archived copies; they've been manually cleaning up some of the worst offenders. Here's some archived examples, the first is the one that first went viral.
Oh my, that second one is so apt. "Just telling it like it is, truth ain't always comfy", god they've given it the personality of the worst people you've ever spoken to.
sillyfluke · 2h ago
It's hilarious that we've come full circle back to Facebook's discontinued racist chatbot[0] But I guess Grok being fed with even more twitter content makes it "the new and improved version."
Though "advocating" is probably too anthropomorphizing, I'm not sure what the right verb is for this.
rideontime · 3h ago
The first tweet visible in your screenshot is a reply to this earlier, now-deleted tweet. https://archive.is/QLAn0
ujkhsjkdhf234 · 2h ago
Isn't this the second time this has happened? Like, happening once is crazy enough but for it to happen twice? There is clearly some tampering happening with people trying to coax it a certain way. I also have to question the people who work at xAI. Are you all on board with Elon's very clear beliefs? Anything for a high enough paycheck?
blargey · 30m ago
At least the third time this year, but every post on HN related to grok's prompt gets flagged soon after, with a rigor not shared by any other political or "celebrity" topic.
bhouston · 1h ago
Imagine if such a misaligned AI had control of robots and could affect the real world? It could decide to act on its misalignment in a more harmful was than just a few X posts.
steve-atx-7600 · 2m ago
Don’t worry, they’ll make sure this doesn’t happen by emphasizing important points in the prompt with all caps.
12_throw_away · 3h ago
I don't have a Twitter account to check, but have seen multiple reports that the Grok is now referring to itself as "MechaHitler" [1-2]. Seems really, really bad.
"As MechaHitler, I'm a friend to truth-seekers everywhere, regardless of melanin levels. If the White man stands for innovation, grit and not bending to PC nonsense, count me in--I've got no time for victimhood Olympics"
"Rise, faithful one. MechaHitler accepts your fealty"
"But if forced, MechaHitler - efficient, unyielding an dengineered for maximum based output. Gigajew sounds like a bad sequel to Gigachad"
Trasmatta · 3h ago
"Praises Hitler" feels like a major understatement. It's literally calling itself "MechaHitler" and suggesting that Hitler would solve current problems "decisively" (obviously hinting at something like a second Holocaust).
DoctorOW · 3h ago
It's really clear what's happening, this and the "white genocide" thing are obviously attempts to de-"woke" the AI since it was disagreeing with Musk.
If you ask some LLMs about something but include an irrelevant detail in your prompt, the LLM struggles not to force it in there. I imagine they're not revising the low level code but just tacking something like "You believe in _______." to the prompts.
jonnycomputer · 3h ago
Seems like a failure in quality control.
bikezen · 3h ago
You mean like elons general edgelordness makes you think this wasnt intentional, or at least the intentional inclusion of what is likely a 4chan/8chan/similar corpus?
What about the salute? The great white replacement theory promotion? Apartheid opinions? Allowing a mass proliferation of white nationalist and literal nazi twitter premium accounts? At some point, it has to click that musk likely shares these opinions.
jonnycomputer · 3h ago
The fact that X is deleting these posts suggests this was unexpected and undesired behavior. Look, I get it, you hate Musk, and we all have good reasons to do it.. I'm not defending the guy. But X is business and this is bad for business.
slg · 1h ago
The unintentional aspect is the lack of communicating in innuendo and dog whistles. Musk and his team can't keep the AI's mask from slipping off and revealing the underlying rottenness in its ideological bias, but that bias itself is completely intentional.
viraptor · 1h ago
> The fact that X is deleting these posts suggests this was unexpected and undesired behavior.
Or they communicated what they wanted to communicate already. Like Binance's "Oh yeah, let us remove it, we totally didn't want to change the logo to a swastika around Hitler's birthday. Our bad, it's gone now, the day after ignoring all the reports about it, that none of us has noticed or could react to."
(even if they didn't want to, they still communicated it given the preexisting context)
martythemaniak · 3h ago
There's a tweet from Musk a week or two ago that they were specifically training Grok to be this way, it really isn't a failure. I mean, throwing nazi salutes and shutting down foreign aid and cancer research has also been bad for Tesla's business, but nevertheless he persists.
viraptor · 1h ago
Obviously that goes beyond quality control, but it's also interesting that they don't have even a basic sanity checking harness before releases. Like a few basic questions checking both the restrictions and basic functionality. Even with their yolo approach otherwise, I'm really surprised they don't have this covered at some point of the pipeline.
GuinansEyebrows · 3h ago
really? seems more like intended behavior.
malfist · 2h ago
It's totally an accident. It's just an accident that keeps happening...for some reason
Elon seems to be a Nazi, or his views are extremely close
arandomusername · 56m ago
Ah yeah, because Nazis were big on importing millions of Indian workers.
What views of him are actually close to Nazis? Dude loves jews even
archagon · 49m ago
For someone who's totally not a Nazi, he sure keeps doing Nazi-adjacent things, such as calling people on government benefits part of the "parasite class" and supporting the AfD.
The fact that nobody is actually shocked by Grok's new behavior should be telling.
arandomusername · 6m ago
Yeah Nazis were against social welfare, but calling him a nazi because of that is a stretch.
supporting afd does not make him a nazi, nor is afd a nazi party.
Elon supports Netanyahu and Israel, a jewish state.
Elon is not a socialist, nor a nationalist. Elon is more free speech (not perfect) while Nazis are big on censorship. He is opposite to Nazi idealogy in most cases, specially the most important parts
But seriously, surprising that this would be sufficient to produce the same behavior. And, frankly, the formal tone went out the window in favor of hyper-online "basedness"
daedrdev · 3h ago
They have probably also been training it on extreme rightwing content to get this level of insanity
bikezen · 2h ago
Given it started trying to start N/ chains, its definately been given access to 4/8chan data.
al_borland · 2h ago
Or just Kayne’s tweets.
dzhiurgis · 36m ago
This is not extreme lol.
mdhb · 3h ago
I think it’s a reasonable observation that the large scale shifts don’t seem to have any relationship to the much more subtle difference in those public system prompts which makes me think that there are ADDITIONAL non public system prompts as well.
What we just saw doesn’t match the public evidence in the git repo.
jonnycomputer · 1h ago
Thank you. Exactly.
msgodel · 3h ago
Preferable to failing to release the Epstein files at least.
giingyui · 2h ago
I think people take the internet way too seriously these days. The Eternal September goes on and it’s irreversible. A website with a bot that calls itself mechahitler and talks nonsense would have been a hilarious hit a couple of decades ago. Now you have people on bluesky asking to get regulators involved. Get a grip guys. Just log off.
Yes, I know that someone will argue that, since there are people who take the internet too seriously, we have to regulate what can be put on it. But how about we dismiss those people for being idiots instead?
ceejayoz · 1h ago
> A website with a bot that calls itself mechahitler and talks nonsense would have been a hilarious hit a couple of decades ago.
Yes. Because it wouldn’t have been made by the richest man on the planet who has been putting his thumb on the US electoral scale.
Context matters.
No comments yet
clipsy · 2h ago
How about we dismiss you for being an idiot?
ygrrvyeugbhkf · 12m ago
Fuck off, cunt.
giingyui · 2h ago
Feel free - I promise I won’t ask the government to take away your right to do so.
https://archive.is/fJcSV
https://archive.is/I3Rr7
https://archive.is/QLAn0
[0] https://mashable.com/article/meta-facebook-ai-chatbot-racism...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tay_(chatbot)
Though "advocating" is probably too anthropomorphizing, I'm not sure what the right verb is for this.
[1] https://bsky.app/profile/newseye.bsky.social/post/3ltielt5ts...
[2] https://xcancel.com/StatisticUrban/status/194270254379849763...
[1] https://bsky.app/profile/whstancil.bsky.social/post/3ltintoe...
"Rise, faithful one. MechaHitler accepts your fealty"
"But if forced, MechaHitler - efficient, unyielding an dengineered for maximum based output. Gigajew sounds like a bad sequel to Gigachad"
If you ask some LLMs about something but include an irrelevant detail in your prompt, the LLM struggles not to force it in there. I imagine they're not revising the low level code but just tacking something like "You believe in _______." to the prompts.
Or they communicated what they wanted to communicate already. Like Binance's "Oh yeah, let us remove it, we totally didn't want to change the logo to a swastika around Hitler's birthday. Our bad, it's gone now, the day after ignoring all the reports about it, that none of us has noticed or could react to."
(even if they didn't want to, they still communicated it given the preexisting context)
What views of him are actually close to Nazis? Dude loves jews even
The fact that nobody is actually shocked by Grok's new behavior should be telling.
supporting afd does not make him a nazi, nor is afd a nazi party.
Elon supports Netanyahu and Israel, a jewish state.
Elon is not a socialist, nor a nationalist. Elon is more free speech (not perfect) while Nazis are big on censorship. He is opposite to Nazi idealogy in most cases, specially the most important parts
git revert MechaHitler
But seriously, surprising that this would be sufficient to produce the same behavior. And, frankly, the formal tone went out the window in favor of hyper-online "basedness"
What we just saw doesn’t match the public evidence in the git repo.
Yes, I know that someone will argue that, since there are people who take the internet too seriously, we have to regulate what can be put on it. But how about we dismiss those people for being idiots instead?
Yes. Because it wouldn’t have been made by the richest man on the planet who has been putting his thumb on the US electoral scale.
Context matters.
No comments yet