tl;dr - inventing the wheel wasn’t the hard part, it was inventing the structure to connect wheels to a static system.
I think this is true for a lot of other inventions too. What we usually point to as the invention is really just the surface of a whole system that had to come together. The iPod, for example, wasn’t just a music player. It only worked because mini hard drives, batteries, mp3 compression, etc. The thing we remember as the invention is really the moment when all the pieces finally clicked.
necovek · 1d ago
While I agree with that, this is the reason I doubt the claim in the article that "wheel" (including the axle connection) was only invented "once" — there is no support for it in the article.
As all of these technologies come into existence, some "inventions" become inevitable.
Sure, maybe a wheeled cart was constructed in one place first by 20 or 50 years, but we are talking about a time where knowledge did not travel far or fast. We had independent discoveries of the same thing in 19th century that were spread out by 20 years, I'd think it was even more 3500 BC.
I think this is true for a lot of other inventions too. What we usually point to as the invention is really just the surface of a whole system that had to come together. The iPod, for example, wasn’t just a music player. It only worked because mini hard drives, batteries, mp3 compression, etc. The thing we remember as the invention is really the moment when all the pieces finally clicked.
As all of these technologies come into existence, some "inventions" become inevitable.
Sure, maybe a wheeled cart was constructed in one place first by 20 or 50 years, but we are talking about a time where knowledge did not travel far or fast. We had independent discoveries of the same thing in 19th century that were spread out by 20 years, I'd think it was even more 3500 BC.