Claude Research refuses to answer questions about cytotoxic mushrooms

4 posix_compliant 4 8/3/2025, 10:17:29 PM

I originally asked the following query: “Could you please find me papers which originally establish the cytotoxicity of Amanita Brunnescens, without referencing another source to do so.”

When promoting it with this query, its response was “ Claude is unable to respond to this request, which appears to violate our Usage Policy. Please start a new chat.”

I split the query into two parts, and first asked: “Are you able to help me answer questions about cytotoxicity?”

To which it gave an enthusiastic response: “ I'd be happy to help you with questions about cytotoxicity! To make sure I provide the most relevant information, could you clarify a few things…”

When following up with “It’s about a particular mushroom”, it responds with the same error message.

I wonder if Claude is overfitting on avoiding questions about mushrooms as a whole because they could be related to psychedelic mushrooms and drug-related concepts.

Comments (4)

muzani · 5h ago

Claude is currently the most prudish LLM. GPT today will happily write on this and all kinds of other taboo things.

morkalork · 5h ago

Might just be because they don't want to be liable if someone eating wild mushrooms dies, regardless of if they are magic or not. A "mushroom hunting identification app" using their API could be a nightmare scenario.

rl3 · 4h ago

>A "mushroom hunting identification app" using their API could be a nightmare scenario.

Where hallucinations in the LLM's brain then lead to hallucinations (or worse) in the user's brain. Ah, what a crazy world we live in.

sinenomine · 6h ago

Have you tried Kimi K2, deepseek R1 and Qwen?

Converge (YC S23) well-capitalized New York startup seeks product developers (runconverge.com)

Great Question (YC W21) Is Hiring a VP of Engineering (Remote) (ycombinator.com)

Coverage Cat (YC S22) Is Hiring a Senior, Staff, or Principal Engineer (coveragecat.com)

Kaizen (YC X25) is hiring engineers to build browser agents that work (kaizenautomation.com)

Infracost (YC W21) hiring first PM to shift $600B cloud spend to proactive (ycombinator.com)

Sei (YC W22) Is Hiring a Full Stack Engineer in Chennai, India (ycombinator.com)

Artie (YC S23) Is Hiring Founding AEs (ycombinator.com)

Cedana (YC S23) Is Hiring a Systems Engineer (ycombinator.com)

CodeCrafters (YC S22) is hiring first Marketing Person (ycombinator.com)

PAX Markets (YC W25) is hiring a founding principal hardware (RTL) engineer (ycombinator.com)

Sendblue (YC S23) is hiring senior engineers (ycombinator.com)

Thunder Compute (YC S24) Is Hiring a C++ Systems Engineer (ycombinator.com)

Optery (YC W22) Is Hiring in Engineering, Legal, Sales, Marketing (U.S., Latam) (optery.com)

QuestDB (YC S20) Is Hiring a Technical Content Lead (questdb.com)

Depot (YC W23) Is Hiring a Technical Content Writer (Remote) (ycombinator.com)

Firebender (YC W24) Is Hiring (ycombinator.com)

Better Auth (YC X25) Is Hiring (ycombinator.com)

Kapa.ai (YC S23) is hiring a software engineers (EU remote) (ycombinator.com)

Spice Data (YC S19) Is Hiring a Product Associate (New Grad) (ycombinator.com)

Extend (YC W23) is hiring engineers to build SOTA document processing (jobs.ashbyhq.com)

Piramidal (YC W24) is hiring a full stack engineer (ycombinator.com)

Mango Health (YC W24) Is Hiring (ycombinator.com)

Resolve (YC W15) Is Hiring an Operations and Billing Lead for Construction VR

Arva AI (YC S24) Is Hiring an AI Research Engineer (London, UK) (arva.ai)

Rejoy Health (YC W21) Is Hiring (ycombinator.com)

Weave (YC W25) is hiring an AI engineer (ycombinator.com)

CoinTracker (YC W18) is hiring to solve crypto taxes and accounting (remote)

Crimson (YC X25) is hiring founding engineers in London (ycombinator.com)

Martin (YC S23) Is Hiring Founding Engineers to Build a Better Siri (ycombinator.com)

Meticulous (YC S21) is hiring in UK to redefine software dev (tinyurl.com)

Infisical (YC W23) Is Hiring DevRel Engineers (ycombinator.com)

Claude Research refuses to answer questions about cytotoxic mushrooms

Comments (4)