Peer review is just internet trolls for science

Comments (4)

phendrenad2 · 1d ago

I was recently made aware of how petty, back-stabby, front-stabby, cliquish, in a word "political" the peer review process can be. I thought that peer-review was a rigorous, objective process, but no, it's just an "old boys" network once again.

uslic001 · 1d ago

I found that out while in medical residency and fellowship. 100% political. Has nothing to do with the validity of a study. It is why I left academic medicine.

fsflover · 1d ago

> JOSS uses the github issue tracker and pull request system to write all reviews for the submitted paper describing the software that was developed

Github is not a good choice for the free and open-source software. It's owned by Microsoft known for its outrageous privacy practices [0]. Github also prevents people from anonymously reading and contributing [1] and so on.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40592789; https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12305598; https://noyb.eu/en/microsofts-xandr-grants-gdpr-rights-rate-...

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43971550

mnky9800n · 1d ago

JOSS created the MVP. I think there is plenty of room to develop the idea further.

Ziina (YC W21) the Series A fintech is hiring product engineers (ziina.notion.site)

Onyx (YC W24) – AI Assistants for Work Hiring Founding AE (ycombinator.com)

Great Question (YC W21) Is Hiring a Director of Customer Success (ycombinator.com)

Deepnote (YC S19) is hiring engineers to build an AI-powered data notebook (deepnote.com)

Converge (YC S23) Well-capitalized New York startup seeks product developers (runconverge.com)

CircuitHub (YC W12) is hiring full-stack robotics engineers (workatastartup.com)

AtoB (YC S20) – Stripe for Transportation – is hiring engineers (jobs.ashbyhq.com)

PromptArmor (YC W24) Is Hiring in San Francisco (ycombinator.com)

Depot (YC W23) is hiring an enterprise support engineer (UK/EU) (ycombinator.com)

Patched (YC S24) Is Hiring SWEs in Singapore (ycombinator.com)

Activeloop (YC S18) Is Hiring Senior Back End and AI Search Engineers(Onsite, MV) (careers.activeloop.ai)

Morph (YC S23) Is Hiring a ML Engineer

Spark AI (YC W24) Is Hiring a Full Stack Engineer in San Francisco (ycombinator.com)

Demodesk (YC W19) Is Hiring Rails Engineers (demodesk.com)

Piramidal (YC W24) Is Hiring a Senior Full Stack Engineer (ycombinator.com)

AccessOwl (YC S22) is hiring an AI TypeScript Engineer to connect 100s of SaaS (ycombinator.com)

StackAI (YC W23) Is Looking for SWR and Tailwind Wizards (ycombinator.com)

Weave (YC W25) is hiring a founding engineer (ycombinator.com)

Infisical (YC W23) Is Hiring Full Stack Engineers (TypeScript) in US and Canada (ycombinator.com)

GoGoGrandparent (YC S16) is hiring Back end Engineers

Roundtable (YC S23) Is Hiring a Member of Technical Staff (ycombinator.com)

Diligent (YC S23) Is Hiring a Founding AI Engineer (ycombinator.com)

Venta AI (YC S23) is hiring a full stack engineer in Amsterdam (ycombinator.com)

Martin (YC S23) Is Hiring Founding AI/Product Engineers to Build a Better Siri (ycombinator.com)

Trellis (YC W24) Is Hiring founding SDR to help automate healthcare paperwork (ycombinator.com)

Sorcerer (YC S24) Is Hiring a Lead Hardware Design Engineer (jobs.ashbyhq.com)

Harper (YC W25) Is Hiring Applied AI / AI Context Engineers and Data Scientist (ycombinator.com)

Overlap (YC S24) Is Hiring (ycombinator.com)

Ashby (YC W19) Is Hiring Engineering Managers (ashbyhq.com)

Glasskube (YC S24) is hiring in Vienna to build Open Source deployment tools (ycombinator.com)

Foundry (YC F24) Is Hiring – Founding Engineer (ML × SWE) (ycombinator.com)

Peer review is just internet trolls for science

Comments (4)