Supreme Court's ruling practically wipes out free speech for sex writing online (ellsberg.substack.com)

Just got to this error page by refreshing my Gmail tab, seeing the Gmail error page, and then refreshing the error page and getting this. Never seen this posted on the Internet before, but I thought it was interesting.

Comments (36)

yegle · 2h ago

This was added in 2004. Before this change, the error message was:

> If too many of these happen, someone will be paged. If you still see this after half an hour, send mail to xxxxxxxxxxx@google.com

(For curious folks working for Hooli, the magic number is 472481)

exiguus · 24m ago

Error page of the error page made me smile. Somehow, this makes total sense to me. Consider a reverse proxy where the origin is down and displaying the 'real' error page is not possible because of that. Alternatively, imagine a CloudFront function or Lambda experiencing the same issue, or encountering so many redirects that it interrupts and simply shows the error page of the error page. Nonetheless, I agree that you shouldn't see this issue very often.

crgk · 4h ago

I’m getting an imgur error page, but it seems this post is meant to be an image of a Google error page?

I’ve reached the error page of the image of the error page for the error page. We’re too deep.

Tiberium · 4h ago

Imgur really hates VPNs, and will show that bogus error page if you're not using a "nice" connection.

andrepd · 3h ago

Lol, so meta.

Also: very sad, but it would be great if it was just imgur doing this; it's the whole internet.

bhaney · 4h ago

Now to refresh this comment until HN randomly goes down

bryanrasmussen · 1h ago

You have reached the error reply to your valued comment. Please send this comment in an email to all your relatives or a bunny will die.

miyuru · 3h ago

Mirror: https://beeimg.com/view/m8002460503/

SchwKatze · 5h ago

You found the easter egg gem!

The fact that google's engineers cared about doing that it's pretty funny

henry700 · 4h ago

Probably done over a decade ago. Today we wouldn't see this

pi_22by7 · 3h ago

oh, for sureee

hnlmorg · 2h ago

That explains why we aren’t talking about it today then.

fnordpiglet · 2h ago

Source code isn’t written afresh every day. The point was the code was written at a different era and the current era wouldn’t produce this sort of code, and presumably you wouldn’t see anything but a generic 500. This is likely because product managers can’t stand free thought and action amongst engineers as it doesn’t appease their bean counter overlords sufficiently.

hnlmorg · 2h ago

You don’t know when that was written.

kartoffelsaft · 1h ago

It had been written by (at the latest) September 2008:

https://googlesystem.blogspot.com/2008/09/best-gmail-error-m...

JadeNB · 1h ago

Wow, seeing someone (presumably) unironically saying "This is why we love Google" was definitely a throwback to an earlier time. https://googlesystem.blogspot.com/2008/09/best-gmail-error-m...

fnordpiglet · 45m ago

That’s pretty presumptuous, but especially so when there are comments parallel from googlers pinning the date and it’s easily determined by using this very powerful information retrieval tool called “Google.” Not to mention the possibility I work at Google, or that I wrote it myself!

jabjq · 2h ago

If you use Google to find this string you will find very old references. (“Very old” is relative)

zaik · 3h ago

Confuse your coworkers by telling them you "won Gmail once".

RandomBacon · 52m ago

They'll just think you're going senile and politely agree, telling you to go back and surf the information superhighway.

mister_mort · 4h ago

Always leave a message in "impossible" code paths, you never know who might read it in the end.

rc_mob · 3h ago

You have 7 different gmail accounts eh?

Alex3917 · 3h ago

Yeah unfortunately they are tricky to get rid of once you have them. In theory I can forward the email from one account to another, but in practice it's hard to think through all the weird security issues that might arise from doing so.

dpedu · 1h ago

I've got one I made as a teen, a more professional sounding mature address, one for school, two for two separate google apps domains, and one for work. They pile up over time.

larrymcp · 3h ago

The funny thing is, this error message is hardly less useful than the recent trend of error messages which say only, "Something went wrong".

hinkley · 3h ago

Have you never dealt with customers reporting errors?

Something went wrong is what they will tell you and expect an answer. Doesn’t matter how fancy and detailed the error, you will get back, “it’s broken fix it.”

hnlmorg · 2h ago

Back in the early days of my career and supporting end users, I used to constantly get people say:

   “xxx doesn’t work. I just get an error”

They would never tell me what the error message actually was. And when I asked, the reply often was

   “I don’t remember. I’ve closed it now”.

It used to wind me up rotten. I can forget non-technical people not understanding the error message. But common sense should have kicked in that the error message is important to share with the person trying to fix said error.

magicalhippo · 13m ago

You can dunk on lay people all you want, personally I'm a lot more furious about fellow programmers who thinks it's OK to show an error that says "file not found" without any context like the filename.

Like, help a brother out!

rkagerer · 2h ago

Maybe all errors should be presented with a simple, distinctive and memorable theme - e.g. show a pig photo in that one maybe they'll remember "I got the pig error"

Xss3 · 1h ago

Could make cute pictures and brighten support staffs day. 'I got a pig telling a chicken that the barn is closed??'

netsharc · 50m ago

I was thinking celebrities, but then people will misidentify them.

Each micro-service (in 2025?!?!) would have different pictures of a particular celebrity, for different errors.. so if the user says e.g. "I see Taylor Swift doing..." the support can say "Let me forward you to the S3 people!".

tough · 1h ago

lmfao this is genius and would work better than text

lostlogin · 1h ago

That’s a good idea - and even technical users would find that more memorable than 1198854 versus a 1197854 error.

JadeNB · 1h ago

> Maybe all errors should be presented with a simple, distinctive and memorable theme - e.g. show a pig photo in that one maybe they'll remember "I got the pig error"

This sounds like the thing that they do in parking garages where each level will have a color, an image, or sometimes even a musical theme. (Which is to say, it sounds like a good idea!)

pphysch · 3h ago

What would you expect? IME these are mostly unforeseen 500 errors, logged internally, and not something a client can do anything about (or should know anything about, for security reasons).

ChrisArchitect · 4h ago

Ask HN: GCP Outage?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44605732

LLM Inevitabilism (tomrenner.com)

Adding a feature because ChatGPT incorrectly thinks it exists (holovaty.com)

OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is going to Google (theverge.com)

MacPaint Art from the Mid-80s Still Looks Great Today (blog.decryption.net.au)

Kiro: A new agentic IDE (kiro.dev)

Bypassing Google's big anti-adblock update (0x44.xyz)

Bootstrapping a side project into a profitable seven-figure business (projectionlab.com)

Nvidia won, we all lost (blog.sebin-nyshkim.net)

Linux Reaches 5% Desktop Market Share in USA (ostechnix.com)

Show HN: Ten years of running every day, visualized (nodaysoff.run)

My open source project was relicensed by a YC company [license updated] (twitter.com)

Local-first software (2019) (inkandswitch.com)

Introducing tmux-rs (richardscollin.github.io)

Supabase MCP can leak your entire SQL database (generalanalysis.com)

Let me pay for Firefox (discourse.mozilla.org)

Bitchat – A decentralized messaging app that works over Bluetooth mesh networks (github.com)

Being too ambitious is a clever form of self-sabotage (maalvika.substack.com)

Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity (metr.org)

Reflections on OpenAI (calv.info)

Grok: Searching X for "From:Elonmusk (Israel or Palestine or Hamas or Gaza)" (simonwillison.net)

Are we the baddies? (geohot.github.io)

ETH Zurich and EPFL to release a LLM developed on public infrastructure (ethz.ch)

Supreme Court's ruling practically wipes out free speech for sex writing online (ellsberg.substack.com)

At Least 13 People Died by Suicide Amid U.K. Post Office Scandal, Report Says (nytimes.com)

ChatGPT agent: bridging research and action (openai.com)

Ukrainian hackers destroyed the IT infrastructure of Russian drone manufacturer (prm.ua)

The Rise of Whatever (eev.ee)

Mistral Releases Deep Research, Voice, Projects in Le Chat (mistral.ai)

US Court nullifies FTC requirement for click-to-cancel (arstechnica.com)

Websites hosting major US climate reports taken down (apnews.com)

Show HN: Shoggoth Mini – A soft tentacle robot powered by GPT-4o and RL (matthieulc.com)

Tree Borrows (plf.inf.ethz.ch)

How does a screen work? (makingsoftware.com)

Mercury: Ultra-fast language models based on diffusion (arxiv.org)

Happy 20th Birthday, Django (djangoproject.com)

Oakland cops gave ICE license plate data; SFPD also illegally shared with feds (sfstandard.com)

Postgres LISTEN/NOTIFY does not scale (recall.ai)

Hidden interface controls that affect usability (interactions.acm.org)

Cloudflare 1.1.1.1 Incident on July 14, 2025 (blog.cloudflare.com)

Linda Yaccarino is leaving X (nytimes.com)

Nobody has a personality anymore: we are products with labels (freyaindia.co.uk)

Apple's MLX adding CUDA support (github.com)

I extracted the safety filters from Apple Intelligence models (github.com)

Data brokers are selling flight information to CBP and ICE (eff.org)

SVGs that feel like GIFs (koaning.io)

I used o3 to profile myself from my saved Pocket links (noperator.dev)

Open letter accuses BBC board member of having a conflict of interest on Gaza (theguardian.com)

Jane Street barred from Indian markets as regulator freezes $566M (cnbc.com)

Show HN: I wrote a "web OS" based on the Apple Lisa's UI, with 1-bit graphics (alpha.lisagui.com)

Apple's Browser Engine Ban Persists, Even Under the DMA (open-web-advocacy.org)

Dear valued user, You have reached the error page for the error page

Comments (36)