Ask HN: Have you noticed AI critic content being disparaged on HN?
4ciwolex77/14/2025, 10:26:38 PM
Comments (7)
k310 · 18m ago
I get downvoted for posting about the risks of pushing untested software on companies and therefore, the public.
I was a sales engineer for a while and long story short, was a no-hype person. We tested stuff in our labs.
Since I raise what I feel are legitimate concerns (no blinders) I wear my downvotes proudly. Make my day, trolls.
vouaobrasil · 2h ago
Personally, I have made many critical comments on AI. Quite a few have been downvoted. The vast majority of people here, in my opinion, are pro-technology and have a blind spot towards it and have trouble criticizing it deeply. They hold the instrumental view of technology that it is just a tool, that we should learn to use it properly, and that technology generally improves the human condition. And of course, a large proportion of people are blinded by the fact that they make a LOT of money with AI, so of course there is a strong bias towards it.
Yes, some people do hold mild negative view of specific companies or how some technology is used, but the criticism is usually exceptionally mild towards a general class of technologies.
There is very little room for true critical discussion here. I still occasionally comment because I think AI is a net detriment to humanity and to the world and I feel the need to speak about it, but it is absolutely true that there is a very strong pro-tech bias that precludes real discussion.
In my opinion, the vast majority of responses to critical AI content here have been knee-jerk reactions with very little thought put into them.
I was a sales engineer for a while and long story short, was a no-hype person. We tested stuff in our labs.
Since I raise what I feel are legitimate concerns (no blinders) I wear my downvotes proudly. Make my day, trolls.
Yes, some people do hold mild negative view of specific companies or how some technology is used, but the criticism is usually exceptionally mild towards a general class of technologies.
There is very little room for true critical discussion here. I still occasionally comment because I think AI is a net detriment to humanity and to the world and I feel the need to speak about it, but it is absolutely true that there is a very strong pro-tech bias that precludes real discussion.
In my opinion, the vast majority of responses to critical AI content here have been knee-jerk reactions with very little thought put into them.