Ask HN: Programmers and lawyers should be so similar, why aren't we?

Assume you’re an eccentric centi-billionaire that wants to create a new desktop/server-class OS that can match Windows, macOS, and Linux in performance, compatibility, and security, and be sold commercially as a competitor.

What would it cost to develop from scratch? How many engineers do you need? How many lawyers?

Comments (4)

sema4hacker · 1h ago

You'll probably have to spend more money on marketing to try to get people to use it than you will on engineering just to create it.

alganet · 2h ago

I'm not eccentric or rich, that's not my problem to solve. Good luck!

Anyway, why do you think that's a problem you need to think of?

No comments yet

unsupp0rted · 2h ago

All the current commercial operating systems today are basically interchangeable, not counting a handful of design decisions (e.g. Finder vs. Explorer) or hardware compatibility.

They're all basically the same thing.

Heck Android and iOS are basically the same thing.

Would a new commercially viable OS be able to offer anything that current ones don't? If not, it's not really commercially viable.

bigyabai · 2h ago

Commercially-viable? Windows and MacOS are both basically given away for free these days. It's been this way on the server for decades; commercial viability means the user pays nothing.

You could probably spend a trillion dollars reinventing the kernel and still lose out to Linux in a world where the internet still exists. If you insist on a commercialized outcome then no amount will really be enough.

Ask HN: Programmers and lawyers should be so similar, why aren't we?

StaAgent: An Agentic Framework for Testing Static Analyzers (arxiv.org)

How Frank Lloyd Wright doomed his masterpiece (thetimes.com)

19 Years on One Product: Things Xmind Taught Me

Leak Reveals the Workaday Lives of North Korean IT Scammers (wired.com)

To the unfeeling killers of gazans [video] (youtube.com)

Ask HN: Programmers and lawyers should be so similar, why aren't we?

VibeApply – Free Hiring App Builder with Dashboard for Sorting Applicants (vibeapply.app)

Got a non-emergency request for Toronto police? You can now call *877 (cbc.ca)

Spanner columnar engine: Powering next-generation analytics on operational data (cloud.google.com)

Texas Tribune experiment: learning ways to engage with "news avoiders" (texastribune.org)

The Doom of YC?

The Fundamentals Still Matter (jordangoodman.bearblog.dev)

Instagram's map feature spurs user backlash over geolocation privacy concerns (cnbc.com)

How to Not Build the Torment Nexus (buttondown.com)

Progress is destroying the planet: the rants of a self-hating American (spectator.co.uk)

EO Against Debanking (twitter.com)

Dear Google, I Love You, but You're Gaslighting Us (seoforlunch.com)

A comparative exploratory analysis of altmetric mentions between X and Bluesky (sciencedirect.com)

H.267: A Codec for (One Possible) Future (streamingmedia.com)

No Model Selector, Always the Best Models (kvncnnlly.com)

A surprising instance of catastrophic floating point errors in biology (arxiv.org)

Show HN: From Hacking a T480 to the Fastest Open-Hardware 75 Hz E-Ink Display (crowdsupply.com)

Staying Relevant (zeldman.com)

AI could widen the wealth gap, Erik Brynjolfsson says (text.npr.org)

Asahi Linux Progress Report (asahilinux.org)

'I Feel Like I'm Going Crazy': ChatGPT Fuels Delusional Spirals (wsj.com)

Economic Productivity, Technology and Wage Growth

Tucson votes down $250M Amazon data center citing water and energy use (foxbusiness.com)

The Browser Company's AI browser now has a $20 subscription (theverge.com)

Captify – Captions for Real Life (captify.glass)

Show HN: Write automation in an IDE and deploy no-code MCP servers (cospec.ai)

GPT-5 really likes tool calling (promptslice.com)

Reflections on Soviet Amateur Photography (publicbooks.org)

Letter of Credit Process for Small-Scale Contracting Using Smart Contracts (dergipark.org.tr)

Intel's CEO, Under Attack from Trump, Is Already at Odds with His Board (wsj.com)

Air Force to deny retirement pay to transgender members separated from service (apnews.com)

The Bittern Lesson for Bioacoustics (arxiv.org)

OpenAI Status: GPT-5 rollout outage (status.openai.com)

Battery Was Almost Too Dangerous to Exist (Veritasium) (youtube.com)

Google says it's working on a fix for Gemini's "I am a failure" comments (businessinsider.com)

LMRouter: Run Claude Code on Any LLM with One Command (github.com)

HTML Traits (github.com)

Show HN: GPT-5 summaries of today's top HN stories and comments (hackernewsdaily.com)

Vulnerabilities in EG4 Inverters (cisa.gov)

These nuclear reactors fit on a flatbed truck. How safe are they? (washingtonpost.com)

Bag of words, have mercy on us (experimental-history.com)

Hubble catches sharpest image yet of 3I/ATLAS (skyatnightmagazine.com)

Google ending Steam for Chromebook support in 2026 (9to5google.com)

High costs and thin margins threatening AI coding startups (techcrunch.com)

Ask HN: How much would it cost to build a new commercially viable OS?

Comments (4)